Russ, I think you are a great guy, an excellent motorcycle rider and obviously knowledgable in firearms. If a guy is a good handgun shot and can empty a 6 round clip in 6 seconds or less in a 4" circle, 25 yards away, he/she can be my partner in Watts, where I spent my career. I don't know about match competition and big sights other than when a friend hands me one and says, "try this". When there is no time limit to squeeze off a round, when perfect sight allignment is achieved, when breatherelaxaimslacksqueeze is performed.....then maybe surgical precision can be the measurement.
In my combat training (both as a student and as an instructor), we determined hits based on the location of vital organs on a silhouette target. I was a distinguished expert pistol shot based on a monthly qualification of >290 out of 300 on a circular target and I never put everything inside of a 2" circle! If the timing component was removed, then maybe but I'm not sure. I do remember some of the guys traveled all over for competitive shooting and spent alot of money on match quality firearms.
I think that speaks to the difference between match performance and monthly range qualification for coppers (at least in LA). Doyle