So I finally made my decision after weeks of flip-flopping over which way to go. I really like the Tobins comfort and the custom stitching, and wanted to go that route, but ultimately the deciding factor for me was the rear seat and backrest of the Corbin. I wanted to be able to give the wife and kids rides from time to time without them being afraid of falling off.
I ended up going with the carbon fiber leather on all 3 pieces, so that should look good with my carbon fiber HMF cans. After the bike week discounts, prices came out to:
$215 front
$215 rear
$197 oval backrest with cf plate backing
They didn't have it all in stock, so I'll post pics after it's delivered and on the bike.