Why your one vote doesn't REALLY count

WWJD

Donating Member
Registered
HowStuffWorks "History of the Electoral College"

How Electoral College works: [summary]

The Electoral College is a controversial mechanism of presidential elections that was created by the framers of the U.S. Constitution as a compromise for the presidential election process. AT THE TIME, some politicians believed a purely popular election was too reckless, while others objected to giving Congress the power to select the president. The compromise was to set up an Electoral College system that allowed voters to vote for electors, who would then cast their votes for candidates, a system described in Article II, section 1 of the Constitution.

the Electoral College includes 538 electors, 535 for the total number of congressional members.

there have been times when electors have voted contrary to the people's decision, which is entirely legal.

there is no federal law that requires an elector to vote according to their pledge (to their respective party). And so, more than a few electors have cast their votes without following the popular vote or their party.


and blah blah blah, read the rest if ya want. So, basically after my entire state votes, it's up to out SEVEN Electors to make the FINAL decision... and they don't even have to follow the parties votes or people's popular vote. And that happens often. Why not skip everything and leave it up to those magic 7 to begin with?

So, if my state votes the majority on one side and we have the majority. and the ELECTORAL COLLEGE votes the other side, how did my one vote count at all. Anyone?

Nice.
 
I am so glad you started this thread!

Last night in the car hubby and I were having a discussion about the electoral college and if the people's votes actually mean anything. Being in Texas we have the two step process, Vote then Caucus. That is how at the primary leve Hilliary got the popular vote but Obama got the greater share of the electoral vote in the end.

I would like to hear some opionions of others on this situation as my knowledge is limited to that of high school and college American History classes. It has been awhile since I have sat my arse in a class! LoL!

So in the words of the great "Coffee Talk" lady....."Discuss"
 
I don't think there has been a case where the candidate with the popular vote didn't win the election anyway. (Seems to me I remember hearing about one case but I'm not sure).

I don't the electorial college is a bad idea, it stops loonies from a large populated specific geographic location from running the whole show. (I'm mainly thinking about CommieFornia as an example :whistle:)
 
Right. Illusion. I'm told my whole life my ONE VOTE matters. No it doesn't if my "Popular" vote doesn't not count in the end through the electoral college. "You one vote could decide the next president...". Not really. So why does this antiquated idea continue to exist? Maybe it is easier to control.

Hate to seem so negative sounding, but I don't vote because my vote does not matter. If the College was gone, I'd vote.

And how could California control the election? They have many more Electoral College votes anyway so what is the diff?

Maybe a POPULAR VOTE count would actually make a difference in elected officials someday.
 
I have been telling people that your 1 vote has never counted! I wouldn't waste my time voting. As I have stated before, they should all be shot, and then thrown in a landfill. Then hire 12th graders to run the country!
 
I have been telling people that your 1 vote has never counted! I wouldn't waste my time voting. As I have stated before, they should all be shot, and then thrown in a landfill. Then hire 12th graders to run the country!

AGREED! If our government were a BUSINESS, it would have been outsourced YEARS ago to someone with skills :)
- officals that vote their own raises and work 5 months a year?
- welfare system that rewards negative effort
- overspending. nuff said

I want FEDEX to take over the government
 
Your vote does indeed count. If your vote did not count, why does both parties have folks out knocking on doors during every presidential ellection.

Unless you want your country to become a Socialist enviroment such as Russia and China, VOTE! It's your ONLY voice in government.
 
Your vote does indeed count. If your vote did not count, why does both parties have folks out knocking on doors during every presidential ellection.

Unless you want your country to become a Socialist enviroment such as Russia and China, VOTE! It's your ONLY voice in government.

Uummm..Der, it's called campaign "in the pocket" money! When is the last time any of these no good money stealing crooks done anything good for this country? They keep taking and taking from us, and there aint nothing we can do about it!
It will never change......I ageee, it should be run as a business. It is soo corrupt, that I wouldn't vote just for the fact that I would be just as bad as them, for involving myself. Which makes me just as bad.
 
The ONLY reason he didn't have a chance was because of the Electoral College. If the American people really had a say, he would have had one heck of a shot. By the way...I have never voted either. It's a great way for the government to gather more information about you and nothing else.
 
I don't think there has been a case where the candidate with the popular vote didn't win the election anyway. (Seems to me I remember hearing about one case but I'm not sure).

I believe Al Gore won the popular vote, but lost the election
 
I did vote ONCE a few years back.... then I got called for JURY DUTY about 4 times since. I'm the LAST GUY you want on any jury. Never again.

Yes, I recall when Ross was TALKING SENSE, then failed. Same with whats his name, Ron Paul? I HEARD things that make sense from him. I've heard nothing but uppity wishes and mud slinging from current choices. I thought reality mattered. I thought wrong. I do beleive if the PEOPLE's votes mattered, Ross and Ron might have had a shot
 
Last edited:
My ONE vote especially doesn't count if you live in MISSISSIPPI... I think we have ONE electoral college vote? ???
 
Back
Top