how about a ducati 750 monster? I've got one for sale at the moment that will fit into the lower part of your price range..
I think it would make an excellent starter bike..
nice torque, decent horsepower.. cheaper on insurance that the japanese bikes because most younger kids don't have them.. it's pretty cool looking.. and hell.. it's a Ducati! lol Excellent handling, and other wordly braking.. will damn near literally stop on a dime and give you .8 cents back. It's light.. only 380 pnds, and comfortable enough for normal riding. Plus it sounds awesome.
now the downside..
valve adjustments every 6,000 miles that run about $300.... $400 if you need belts (12,000 miles, or every two years.
if your interested in hearing more check this page out
http://www.pureegoworld.com/ducati.htm
now don't misunderstand.. just because it's a 750 don't expect to be winning any races against gsxr600s... but it's pretty even with an SV650... only you aren't gonna pass 15 every time you hit the biker hangouts.
Your not gonna hurt it (probably) by dropping it in your driveway.. but if you do break something the parts are higher than jap peices... (IE gas tank.. $1,600) 'bout the worst thing you could do is the gas tank.. good news is it's pretty tough and can be repaired for about $250 if ya just ding it.
later, and good luck with whatever your getting into.