I have a pair of the Fieldsheer gloves with Kangaroo palms. By far the most comfy gloves I have ever worn. I did crash in the first pair I had and didn't get a mark on me other than my little finger on my right hand. The glove opened up and my little finger was exposed and bleeding. I tossed that pair and went back for seconds and bought another identical pair. Hard headed I guess but I love the gloves for comfort. Street only, I don't do track events with them. For that I use my Joe Rocket Speedmasters or Alpinestar Pros.
I have no crash history in fieldsheer other than gloves. I do have an interesting comment to share made by our Joe Rocket Rep whom we get our Joe Rocket gear through. She gave Fieldsheer the lowest marks of any of the available gear on the market including Icon. I did not ask for details but I do put a certain ammout of faith in her since leathers is her game.
I have no opinion, just sharing my experience.