If the cylinders still have 175+psi, its something else. Now its time to start checking for spark/fuel etc. Something else is missing for it not to run. I'd check for spark first, then verify fuel pressure. If both of those check out, then its time to start testing the sensors...(MAP, Crank, cam etc).....
Its definetly not melted with 175psi....if it was toasted, even lightly toasted, you would have well under 100psi....if any at all so thats a good sign for you..
You held the throttle 100% open when doing the comp test right?